Choosing the right carpet installation method is crucial for enhancing the comfort and aesthetic appeal of your home. With various options available, it can be overwhelming to decide which one is best suited for your needs. This decision should be made by the flooring installation professional, but it doesn’t hurt to have an understanding of the options available. This article delves into 3 common types of carpet installations, offering insights into their advantages, disadvantages, and what homeowners should consider before proceeding. Whether you’re replacing old carpet or installing new carpet, understanding these options will help you make an informed decision.

Stretch-In Installation


  • Flexibility: This installation method is the most common technique found in residential floor covering. Subfloor prep is most forgiving here because we are not trying to bond materials to the floor. Replacement down the road is also made easier by the fact that the padding and carpet are not permanently attached to the floor. The tackstips used in a stretch-in installation are usually good for several installs as well. Stretch-in carpet on stairs is the safest way to redo a set of steps due to the slip resistance and cushion provided.

  • Comfort: Provides a cushioned feel underfoot, enhancing comfort. Because we are installing a separate cushion underneath the carpet, we can select a product that best meets the needs of the homeowner. Options include different densities that affect feel under foot, as well as moisture barriers that resist liquid messes such as pet urine and spills. 

  • Cost: Stretch-in carpet is considered the most economical way to cover the floors in most rooms of the home. Natural materials like wool are available, and a person could invest a small fortune on carpet if they wish, but there are many low cost options as well.


  • Requires Skilled Installation: Improper stretching can lead to wrinkles and premature wear. I can’t stress this enough. There is a growing trend of installers using tools and installation methods that will all but guarantee a failure down the road. Setting up the proper tools and using the right methods takes extra time and effort. You will not notice the difference in the first year, which is why these methods have almost become the new standard, but you are losing years of useful life from your investment when this happens. When installed properly, under the approved conditions, you should not need to address wrinkles within the first several years. 

  • Damage to other Surfaces: Stretch-in installation can be a labor intensive practice. A roll of carpet for a living room can weigh a few hundred pounds. The standard backing on carpet is equal to a 16 grit sandpaper. Cutting, fitting, and shifting materials into place can cause minor scuffs and marks that will require touch-up afterwards. A good installer will keep this to a minimum. 

Stretch-in carpet installations are a popular choice for residential spaces due to their comfort and adaptability. However, the key to longevity with this method is professional installation and proper site conditions (temperature controlled). 

Glue-Down Installation


  • Durability: Offers a firm and stable surface, reducing shifts and movements. It’s no secret that one key to carpet longevity is lack of movement. The more a piece of carpet is allowed to move (thick, soft padding) under foot traffic, the faster the backing breaks down, leading to wrinkles. Direct glue down installation addresses this by eliminating the padding and need for stretch by gluing the entire piece to the subfloor.  

  • Suitability for High Traffic Areas: Ideal for commercial spaces. It’s rare to see a direct glue installation in a residential home, but it is an option. The most common place we see this is patios, decks, and sun rooms. This does require materials and adhesives rated for the outdoor environment.


  • Harder Underfoot: Less comfortable compared to stretch-in installations. This is usually a negative when we think about a family laying on the floor enjoying a game night, movie, or an infant crawling around. *NOTE* If the use of mobility aids such as a walker are a part of daily life, a direct glue installation might be the answer.

  • Difficult to Remove: Removal can be labor-intensive and may damage the subfloor.

Glue-down installations are best for areas that see a lot of foot traffic. While they offer durability, they lack the underfoot comfort that other methods provide.

Carpet Tiles


  • Versatility: Easy to replace individual tiles instead of the entire carpet. When properly installed, carpet tiles are fairly easy to replace. Carpet tile construction addresses the issue of wrinkling and raveling that can be found with standard and unitary backed carpets. This, combined with the direct glue method, make for a durable and serviceable floor. These products are typically found in commercial applications more than the home, but we do see carpet go into a home office or gym space.

  • Design Flexibility: Available in various colors and patterns for custom designs. This allows us to add a custom touch to an otherwise standard floor option. Carpet tiles are available in many sizes and shapes, lending it to some creative applications.


  • Visible Seams: Tiles may show seams, affecting the overall look. If your idea of the perfect carpeted space is seeing one large, continuous piece, carpet tile is not going to be the best option.

  • Adhesive Issues: This is more of an installation and specification problem than the adhesive itself. Carpet tile and its adhesives require the right conditions to be successful. Concrete moisture vapor emissions and inappropriate subfloor conditions will have an affect on performance. 

Carpet tiles are an excellent option for those looking for design flexibility and ease of maintenance, in a commercial setting. However, the visibility of seams and the quality of adhesive and installation experience are important considerations.

Self-Adhesive Carpet Tiles

We do not recommend this option without knowing the full application and specifications of the materials.


  • Easy Installation: Simple peel-and-stick application process. Troweling out adhesive can be a disastrous process for the inexperienced. Peel and still addresses this issue. Expect to use a roll on primer when going this route. Most find rolling on primer much easier than troweling. 

  • Convenience: Someone with basic tools and knowledge of construction can typically make due.


  • Limited Durability: May not be suitable for high-traffic areas. The materials and adhesive are usually marked towards the DIY crowd, where workability is favored over long term quality. Better materials are usually more difficult to cut and fit.

  • Adhesive Quality: The adhesive can weaken over time, leading to tiles lifting. Good prep and proper primer is crucial here. Unfortunately, these are areas best left to the professionals, eliminating the DIY benefit of a peel and stick installation.

Self-adhesive carpet tiles offer a DIY-friendly option, but their durability and the longevity of the adhesive are potential downsides.

Installation Costs: Carpet

The cost of carpet installations can vary widely depending on the method chosen and the size of the area to be covered. Stretch-in and glue-down installations of both rolled carpet (broadloom) and carpet tile typically require professional expertise, increasing the overall cost. Care should be taken to ensure your installation company is using industry best practices. Failure to do so may void any warranty the manufacturer offers. Self-adhesive carpet tiles might offer a more cost-effective solution for those on a budget. Always consider the long-term value and potential future costs associated with each type.

DIY vs Professional Carpet Installation

DIY carpet installations can save money upfront but may not always provide the best results. Carpet is one of the few trades where DIY will not pay off. Professional carpet installations ensure a high-quality finish, longevity, and proper fit, especially for complex spaces or specialized carpet types. Most of the tools used are specific to the trade, meaning the average homeowner would need to buy or rent them. Add in the fact that improper installation can cost several years of useful life to the carpet and it’s easy to see why professional installation is the best way to go. Those who dare to take it on tend to appreciate the craft that much more afterwards. 

    Professional Carpet Installation: How

    Opting for professional carpet installation guarantees expertise and experience, ensuring your carpet is installed correctly. Professionals can handle unexpected issues, provide warranties, and ensure compliance with manufacturer guidelines, which is especially important for maintaining your carpet’s warranty.

      Carpet Installation: How to Save

      Getting new carpet installed is not just for the pros. If you find yourself on a tight budget, here are some things you can do to save on cost.

      • Move the furniture. The rooms need to be empty to install new carpet. Your installation crew can assist with this, but it will come at a cost. If possible, clear the space out ahead of time.
      • Remove the old carpet. Many homeowners elect to remove the existing carpets themselves. Having the carpet and pad pulled, pad glue and/or staples removed, and area swept clean can help save on the labor cost. It’s best to go over this with you installer to make sure everyone is on the same page. 


        Selecting the right carpet installation method for your Medford home involves considering various factors, including cost, durability, comfort, and the specific needs of your space. Whether stretch-in installation,  glue-down, carpet tiles, or self-adhesive tiles is used, each has its pros and cons. Professional guidance can be invaluable in making an informed decision that combines aesthetics, functionality, and value. For further insights, visit [Home – The Carpet and Rug Institute (carpet-rug.org)) for comprehensive guidelines on carpet installations and care. 

        A basic understanding of the methods available and their proper application is good to have. That said, to get the most out of your investment, proper installation will go further than expensive materials. Proceed with caution and ask questions.  

        From Dream to Reality:
        See How We Can Help!

        Other articles you may be interested in: